Google Search Console - Set URL parameter replytocom correctly

Enter replytocom in the field for the parameter.
Select "Yes: changes or sorts the page content or narrows it down" from the drop-down menu.
When asked how this parameter affects the page content, select "Page selection".
And finally, set the selection to the "No URLs" radio button.
Then click on Save.

Read the complete guide to the Yoast SEO plugin!